Last December, ZIP 85018 had 140 single-family homes for sale, the lowest inventory of any month that winter. That count comes from the Phoenix REALTORS® Local Market Update for December 2025. In January 2026, 77 new listings came on in the same ZIP, more than double December's 36. Buyers wrote 28 contracts that month, six more than in December. The case for listing an Arcadia home over the holidays rests on that gap. This fall, mortgage rates have pushed contract activity down across the Valley, which makes the gap more important.
Two notes on the data. ZIP 85018 is wider than Arcadia proper, so this post calls it the Arcadia-area ZIP. And because monthly samples here are small, the useful information is the pattern across months, not any single month's figure.
December Had the Fewest Homes for Sale
Last winter in the Arcadia-area ZIP, inventory dropped sharply going into the holidays. There were 177 single-family homes for sale in November 2025 and 140 in December, and months of supply fell from 5.9 to 4.5. A December buyer had fewer homes to compare than buyers in any of the months around it, and that December figure of 4.5 months was the lowest supply reading in the five months from November through March.
Then the shelf filled back up. Inventory reached 179 in January, 203 in February and 200 in March, according to the monthly updates for January, February and March 2026. By February, months of supply had reached 6.7. In about eight weeks, a seller's competition grew from 140 homes to more than 200.
January Added Sellers Faster Than Buyers
The more telling number is how many buyers each new listing had to share. In December 2025, Arcadia-area buyers wrote 22 contracts against 36 new listings, about six contracts for every ten listings. In January, they wrote 28 contracts against 77 new listings, fewer than four for every ten. February came in near three for every ten, with 16 contracts against 57 new listings.
New listings in January more than doubled, but contracts rose by about a quarter, so January buyers had many more homes to pick from.
The same thing happened across the metro. ARMLS figures in the ShowingTime Phoenix-area market report show 4,939 new single-family listings in December 2025 and 8,801 in January 2026, a jump of about 78 percent. Pending sales over the same two months went from 3,867 to 5,422, a jump of about 40 percent. In a large market and a small ZIP alike, the January rush adds sellers faster than it adds buyers.
Why January Looked Strong Last Year
Last year's January figures can make waiting look smart. Arcadia-area homes that closed in January 2026 sold in a median of 70 days at 96.4 percent of list price. December's closings took 85 days and got 95.3 percent of list.
The two months after January's surge in listings came in slower. Homes that closed in February and March each took a median of 79 days on market, and March closings got 95.5 percent of list price. The gaps are around a percentage point, small but real on an Arcadia price. On a $1.6 million sale, one point of list price is $16,000.
This Fall Makes Timing Matter More
Last winter's pattern played out in a calmer market than the one Arcadia sellers face now. Freddie Mac's weekly mortgage survey put the 30-year fixed rate at 6.71 percent on September 3, 2026, and 7.40 percent on October 15. It eased to 7.11 percent by November 12. ARMLS reported in its November 2026 STAT report that the 30-year rate averaged 7.33 percent in October, against 6.25 percent a year earlier, the highest monthly average in three years.
Buyers pulled back as rates rose. ABC15 reported in early October that Valley pending sales for September were down 40 percent from a year earlier. For October 2026, the same ARMLS STAT report counted active inventory up 9.6 percent from a year earlier and pending, UCB and CCBS contracts down 19.7 percent combined. Months of supply was 6.04, compared with 4.72 in October 2025. The ShowingTime report shows a steeper drop for single-family homes alone: 2,775 pending sales in October 2026, down 45.9 percent year over year. The Cromford Report's early November summary puts the contract ratio at its lowest level since February 2009.
The Arcadia-area ZIP followed the same trend in October 2026. Buyers wrote 18 single-family contracts, down from 30 in October 2025, while new listings rose to 76 from 63. Inventory reached 199 homes, up 8.7 percent from a year earlier. That puts the Arcadia-area shelf going into the holidays well above last year's 177 homes in November and 140 in December. When fewer buyers are writing contracts, a seller can't count on the January crowd to lift every listing. Our October market update covers the earlier part of this slowdown.
The Top of the Market Is Still Selling
October's closings in the Arcadia-area ZIP look nothing like its contract count. Closed single-family sales reached 49, up from 27 a year earlier, at a median of $2,113,500 and 95.9 percent of list price. The report also notes that small samples can make percentage changes look extreme. Through October, the year-to-date median was $1,725,000, up 16.9 percent, and year-to-date contracts were up 15.3 percent.
ARMLS titled its October commentary "A Tale of Two Markets." Closings under $500,000 fell 14.5 percent from a year earlier, while homes above $2 million made up a slightly larger share of sales than in previous months. The Cromford Report has also found that expensive homes near the center of the Phoenix area gained much more in price per square foot over the three years to August 2026 than expensive homes on the edges, in a comparison of 53 neighborhoods. The most expensive end of Arcadia is still trading too. The Arizona Republic reported in September that an Arcadia house with two kitchens sold for $7.5 million, one of the most expensive metro Phoenix closings for the week ended September 9.
Arcadia buyers are still buying, but more slowly and with more homes to choose from. In that market, an owner gains the most from being one of a few good options rather than one of many.
What a December Listing Requires
A holiday listing works only if the house is ready before the holidays begin. Photos, repairs and pricing need to be done by early December, so the home shows well during the weeks when the fewest other homes are for sale. A house that comes on in the middle of January competes with all the homes that held off until the new year.
Price needs the same attention. The Arcadia-area ZIP carried 5.4 months of supply in October 2026, compared with 4.5 months last December. Buyers out this December will have more homes to compare than buyers did a year ago, so a price based on last spring's comparable sales may need another look. The 30-year rate figures above are general market information, not financial advice, so confirm your own numbers with your lender and tax advisor.
Then there's the holiday calendar. A contract written in December puts inspections, appraisals and title work in the weeks when lenders, inspectors and buyers have holiday plans. Our transaction coordinator, Carey Runyon, manages the paperwork from contract to close, and a December listing needs that deadline schedule set early. If you're thinking about selling and leaving Arcadia, our move-up sellers guide covers the timing of a second purchase.
A Few Questions Sellers Ask
Is 85018 the same as Arcadia? No. The ZIP includes Arcadia proper plus parts of Arcadia Lite and other neighborhoods around them. The month-to-month pattern applies across the ZIP, but the value of a specific house depends on its own street, lot and condition. Our guide to the Arcadia median explains why one number can't describe the whole area.
Do condos follow the same pattern? The figures in this post are for single-family homes. In October 2026, the ZIP's condo and townhouse market had 7.7 months of supply, with 5 pending sales against 16 new listings. That calls for a separate pricing approach.
Deciding whether to list in December or January starts with knowing where your home's price falls against this winter's inventory. If you are weighing a holiday listing, The Pontikas Team would be glad to talk it through with you. Get a Free Home Valuation to start with a price before you pick the month.